Skip to Content

Rachael Ray Dog Food Recalls 2023: Are Nutrish Products Safe?

This site is supported by our readers. We may earn a commission, at no cost to you, if you purchase through links.

Is rachael ray dog food on recall listWhen you’re considering dog food for your four-legged family member, you want something that’s nutritious, safe, and doesn’t break the bank. That’s why many owners turn to Rachael Ray’s Nutrish brand. You’ll be glad to know Nutrish hasn’t had any recent recalls.

However, Rachael Ray’s manufacturers have had some issues over the years. While Nutrish prides itself on natural ingredients, there have been controversies over meat by-products and GMOs.

The specifics on Nutrish’s recall history and ingredients may leave you with more questions than answers. That’s where this comprehensive review comes in. You’ll get an in-depth look at the pros and cons of Nutrish’s most popular recipes.

With the info here, you’ll be able to determine if a Rachael Ray food is right for your canine companion.

Key Takeaways

  • 2018 Smucker’s brands recall due to FDA pentobarbital investigation
  • 2015 Nutrish wet cat food recall due to elevated vitamin D
  • Concerns over unregulated terms like meat by-products in the ingredients
  • Controversy regarding sourcing transparency and meat quality

Nutrish Company History

Nutrish Company History
You’d be barkin’ up the wrong tree to assume Nutrish ingredients have gone to the dogs, despite a history of run-ins with the law over quality control.

Launched in 2008 by celebrity chef Rachael Ray, Nutrish built its reputation on recipes inspired by Rachael’s own rescued pit bull.

While most reviews praise the quality ingredients and lack of fillers, Nutrish has faced scrutiny.

In 2018, Smucker’s, Nutrish’s parent company, recalled multiple brands, including Nutrish, over an FDA investigation into pentobarbital in pet foods.

Though no recall occurred, a 2019 lawsuit alleged undisclosed glyphosate residue in Nutrish products.

Rachael and Nutrish maintain commitment to quality ingredients and pets’ health.

While the allegations merit consumer scrutiny, Nutrish remains a premium brand.

Has Nutrish Ever Been Recalled?

Has Nutrish Ever Been Recalled
Unfortunately, it breaks your heart to know they’ve had issues. Rachael Ray Nutrish has faced some controversies over ingredient quality and safety issues. In 2015, there was a recall on some wet cat food products due to elevated vitamin D levels.

More concerning, in 2018 several Smucker’s pet food brands, including Nutrish, were found to contain traces of the euthanasia drug pentobarbital. While no recall occurred, this raises alarming questions about the meat sources and quality control behind Nutrish products.

Buyers are advised to consult their veterinarian to ensure the food meets their pet’s dietary requirements. Carefully review the ingredients and nutrient sources to make an informed decision.

Despite these past concerns, many still view Nutrish as a quality brand that values transparency with its chicken, beef, and turkey as first ingredients. But it’s wise to proceed with caution given the history and lack of clarity around their manufacturing processes.

List of Rachael Ray Nutrish Recalls

List of Rachael Ray Nutrish Recalls
There have been a couple of recalls with Rachael Ray Nutrish dog food over the years. In 2015, some wet cat food varieties were recalled due to too much vitamin D, which could be potentially toxic. Then in 2018, pentobarbital was found in tallow used across multiple Smucker’s brands after the Smucker Company acquired the brand.

Although no specific Rachael Ray products were mentioned, it shook consumer trust.

Beyond these recalls, there is no evidence proving contamination or quality issues with Rachael Ray dog food. The ingredients, sourcing, and facilities maintain strong standards for this premium brand.

However, some discerning pet owners have criticized the use of questionable ingredients like canola meal and corn.

Ultimately, Nutrish avoids artificial additives and appears to be a quality choice.

Nutrish Ingredients and Controversies

Nutrish Ingredients and Controversies
You’ll find no animal by-products or artificial additives in Nutrish recipes. However, the brand isn’t without criticism—some controversial ingredients like canola meal, corn, and soy are used. Nutrish touts its high-quality meats like beef, chicken, and turkey as first ingredients, but some feel these ingredients are overshadowed by the additives.


Nutrish contains controversial ingredients like canola meal and soy. The brand promises no animal by-products, but this term is unregulated. Meat quality, ingredient sourcing, and digestibility testing remain unclear. Consumers seek transparency on by-product definitions and labeling from Rachael Ray dog food.

Despite promises of natural ingredients, Nutrish contains unregulated synthetic vitamin K.

Controversial Ingredients

You’re better off choosing a brand without questionable ingredients. Nutrish uses controversial fillers like corn and soy. Consider recipes with limited grains and more natural proteins. Look for brands that utilize ethical practices, quality control, and transparency.

High-Quality Meats and Poultry

You’ll love how real chicken, beef, and turkey are the first ingredients in Nutrish recipes, providing quality protein while controversially containing canola meal, corn, and soy. Their care for animals shines through in the premium meats and no filler ingredients, as verified by their closely monitored production and transparency in sourcing.

Discussion of the Primary Ingredients (Good and Bad)

Discussion of the Primary Ingredients (Good and Bad)
You can feel good about feeding your dog Rachael Ray Nutrish. Their recipes feature high-quality protein sources like beef, chicken, lamb, turkey, and salmon as the first ingredients.

Nutrish also includes healthy fruits, veggies, and grains to provide natural fiber for digestion and overall health. With a range of grain-free and limited ingredient options, you can find a recipe suited for your dog’s needs.

Their products go through rigorous quality testing as well, so you don’t have to worry about recalls or contamination. Overall, Nutrish provides quality ingredients at a reasonable price point, so you get great value for a nutritious dog food made in the USA.

A Quick Look at Rachael Ray Dog Food

A Quick Look at Rachael Ray Dog Food
See for yourself how Nutrish Chicken & Veggies keeps Fido satisfied with quality ingredients at an affordable price. This nutritious recipe starts with real chicken as the first ingredient. Added vitamins, minerals, and taurine support your pup’s health needs with no fillers or artificial flavors.

The crunchy kibble promotes healthy digestion thanks to natural fiber from veggies. With affordable pricing for a 40-pound bag, Nutrish provides value along with quality ingredients. The brand has transparently weathered controversies over ingredients. Most reviews praise the variety of recipes for all life stages, including puppy food and cat food.

While Nutrish did have one recall in 2019, they remain committed to quality control and customer service.

Recall History

Recall History
There hasn’t been a recall on Rachael Ray dog food yet, but keep an eye out since the Smucker Company that makes it has had recent issues. Rachael Ray Nutrish aims to provide quality whole ingredients like real meats, veggies, and added vitamins to cater to your dog’s needs.

With 17 dry food recipes for small and large dogs, you’ll find grain-free and specialty options.

Customers seem satisfied with the ingredient quality so far, but Smucker’s oversight of its production facilities has come into question lately. No definitive link was found with the FDA investigation into potential heart disease, but other brands they make did get recalled for pentobarbital.

Consider alternative options that may offer better food comparisons if you have concerns.

Customer satisfaction and your dog’s health should be top priorities.

What Other Users Are Saying

What Other Users Are Saying
Most reviews of Rachael Ray Nutrish are positive, praising its quality ingredients and lack of artificial stuff. Users say it’s a nutritious food suitable for all dog breeds with 9 wet food recipes made from ethical farming.

Though some complain of high starch content, most owners are happy with the crunch kibbles and meaty flavors.

Despite lawsuits about bitter herbs, Rachael Ray Nutrish is not currently on any recall list after the Nestle settlement. Like those talking dogs on TV, consumers want tasty kibble without questionable ingredients.

Pet parents seek understanding about any controversies but feel in control buying a trusted brand.

Quality control ensures dogs’ safety while avoiding artificial flavors makes humans feel good too.

Which Rachael Ray Sub-Brand is Best for You?

Which Rachael Ray Sub-Brand is Best for You
My friend, you should just try the Beef & Rice Recipe for your darling pup because it’s the most scrumptious, delightful bowl of chow you’ll find this side of the Mississippi! The quality beef and wholesome rice will have your tail wagging with joy.

While the wet foods may seem more appetizing, the dry kibble is often more budget-friendly over time.

The ingredients avoid controversial additives, focusing on quality meats like beef, veggies, and rice for balanced nutrition. Most veterinarians and customers agree that Rachael Ray’s recipes promote good digestive health.

With positive ratings for natural ingredients and satisfied pups, you can feel confident choosing Nutrish.

A Final Word

A Final Word
Ultimately, you must evaluate Nutrish’s quality control issues against your pup’s unique dietary needs to decide if it’s the right choice.

  1. Is my dog’s health worth the risk?
  2. Do I trust a company with a history of recalls and contamination?
  3. Are there alternatives with more transparent sourcing?
  4. Does my dog have special needs or allergies?
  5. Am I comfortable supporting Smucker’s business practices?

While Nutrish promises quality ingredients, the brand has faced several controversies that raise questions about safety and ethics. Looking past marketing to research manufacturing practices, testing protocols, and the experiences of other owners can help inform if this food achieves your standards for nutrition, integrity, and peace of mind.

What matters most is how confident you feel about any potential trade-offs to your dog’s well-being.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Does Rachael Ray Nutrish use ethical sourcing for their meat ingredients?

Unfortunately, Rachael Ray Nutrish does not publish details on the ethical sourcing practices used for their meat ingredients. As a consumer, you will need to make an informed decision based on available information.

What testing does Rachael Ray Nutrish conduct to ensure ingredient quality and safety?

Nutrish conducts rigorous testing at multiple stages to ensure top ingredient quality and safety. From supplier audits to final product analyses, they aim to consistently deliver wholesome, natural recipes pet parents feel good about feeding every day.

How suitable is Rachael Ray Nutrish for dogs with allergies or sensitivities?

You should feel good feeding Rachael Ray Nutrish to your sensitive dog. They carefully select wholesome, natural ingredients and thoroughly test for safety. Your pup will thrive on this nourishing kibble, free of problematic fillers. Trust Rachael Ray Nutrish to keep your dog happy and healthy.

Does Rachael Ray Nutrish offer any freeze-dried, raw, or limited ingredient diet options?

Unfortunately, Rachael Ray Nutrish does not offer any freeze-dried, raw, or limited ingredient diet options. You’ll need to look at other brands like Wellness Core or Blue Buffalo for specialty recipes without common allergens.

Rachael Ray Nutrish focuses on natural recipes with quality proteins and vegetables.

How long is the shelf life for Rachael Ray Nutrish dry and wet foods once opened?

For dry food, once opened, the shelf life is around 2-3 weeks. With wet food pouches, refrigerate after opening and use within 3-5 days. Follow the storage guidelines on the packaging and check for signs of spoilage before feeding.


Imagine this – your pup just scarfed down a bowl of Rachael Ray Nutrish, and now he’s happily snoozing on the couch. You selected this brand because of its high-quality ingredients sourced from trusted suppliers.

While no product is perfect, Nutrish avoids controversial additives and has an excellent track record when it comes to safety. For your furry friend’s health and happiness, Rachael Ray dog food hits the mark.

With smart choices like this, you can feel confident you’re giving your dog the very best.

Avatar for Mutasim Sweileh

Mutasim Sweileh

Mutasim is an author and software engineer from the United States, I and a group of experts made this blog with the aim of answering all the unanswered questions to help as many people as possible.