Skip to Content

Can Dogs Eat Peanut Butter? 6 Safe Brands for 2023

This site is supported by our readers. We may earn a commission, at no cost to you, if you purchase through links.

Let’s cut to the chase: when it comes to feeding our furry friends, peanut butter is a top contender.

We’ve done all the leg work and rounded up six trusted dog-safe peanut butter brands for 2023.

Not only can they help keep your four-legged friend entertained but there are also some potential health benefits too! Read on as we delve into what ingredients make certain peanut butters unsafe and unhealthy for dogs – plus homemade recipes and alternative options if needed.

Key Takeaways

What brands of peanut butter can dogs eat?

  • Whole Foods Market Peanut Butter Salt, Teddie Peanut Butter Chunky, All Natural Dog Peanut Butter, and IQ Treat Spread Dog Peanut Butter are safe brands of peanut butter for dogs.
  • It is important to avoid peanut butter brands that contain xylitol, as it is toxic to dogs.
  • Homemade peanut butter recipes can be a good alternative to store-bought brands.
  • Peanut butter should be given to dogs in moderation as an occasional treat, not as a regular part of their diet.

Top 6 Dog-Safe Peanut Butter Brands

Top 6 Dog-Safe Peanut Butter Brands
With the variety of peanut butter options on the market, it can be difficult to know which brands are safe for your pup. Luckily, there are some excellent dog-safe choices out there, such as Whole Foods Market Peanut Butter Salt, Teddie Peanut Butter Chunky 3-Pack, All Natural Dog Peanut Butter, and more.

You’ll love Whole Foods Market Peanut Butter Salt for your pup – it’s made with just peanuts and salt, has a fresh roasted peanut flavor, and won’t break the bank!

With 100% U.S.A. Peanuts and no added sugar or oils, this peanut butter is perfect for those looking to give their furry friends something delicious but healthy too.

And since there are no preservatives or artificial ingredients, you can feel good about giving your pup this treat as an occasional reward or snack without worrying about any adverse effects on their health.

Pros
  • Made in the USA with all-natural ingredients
  • No added sugars/oils/preservatives
  • Delicious taste of freshly roasted peanuts
Cons
  • Oil separation may require stirring
  • More expensive than other brands

Try Teddie Peanut Butter Chunky and give your pup a delicious treat that’s been crafted with love since 1925! This peanut butter is the perfect balance of crunchy and creamy, made in the USA using only fresh-roasted peanuts.

It contains no preservatives or added sugars, so you can feel good about giving it to your pup as an occasional reward or snack.

Plus, it has all the benefits of being Non-GMO, Gluten Free, Vegan Friendly, and Kosher too! With its mild flavor profile yet intense crunchiness – this 3 pack will be sure to satisfy even picky pups’ taste buds.

Pros
  • Made in the USA with all-natural ingredients
  • No preservatives or sugars added
  • Delicious taste of freshly roasted peanuts
Cons
  • Oil separation may require stirring
  • More expensive than other brands

Give your pup the naturally delicious taste of Dilly’s Peanut Butter for a healthy treat they won’t be able to resist! This all-natural dog peanut butter is made in the USA with no preservatives or added supplements.

It contains four beneficial ingredients that make it great for crate training and helping with separation anxiety.

The texture can be runny, but putting it in the fridge helps to resolve this issue.

Pros
  • All-natural dog peanut butter made in the USA
  • Contains 4 added benefiting ingredients
  • Great for crate training & helping with separation anxiety
  • Good source of protein & vitamins
  • Dogs love its flavor
Cons
  • Texture may be on the thin side
  • Can become runny if not refrigerated
  • Some customers find it expensive compared to other brands

Experience the ultimate chewing experience with KONG’s Toughest Natural Rubber Dog Toy, designed for large dogs up to 65 lbs. This durable and long-lasting toy is ideal for satisfying your pup’s instinctual needs while providing mental stimulation with its unpredictable bounce.

Vet recommended and dishwasher safe for easy clean-up, this toy can withstand heavy chewing from even 120-pound pit bulls – making it perfect for super chewers looking to have some fun! Not only does this all-natural rubber dog toy encourage healthy play and fetching, but you can also stuff treats like kibble or peanut butter inside as an added bonus! Plus, if you want to add more challenge, then simply place the frozen treat inside before giving it over – great when temperatures rise outside during summertime activities.

All in all, why not give your pup something that they will love?

Pros
  • Designed specifically for large breeds (up to 65 lbs)
  • Encourages healthy play & fetching
  • Unpredictable bounce offers mental stimulation
  • Durable & long-lasting; suitable for extreme chewers
  • Stᆱle with treats like kibble or peanut butter; freezable option available
Cons
  • Smaller than expected; check dimensions before purchasing
  • Lasts longer than other Kong toys, so may finish quicker

Satisfy your pup’s cravings with Organic Peanut Butter: Crunchy, which is packed with natural ingredients and no preservatives or added sugar – perfect for spreading on toast and adding to smoothies!

With an excellent source of protein and fiber, this vegan-friendly peanut butter has a low glycemic index that can help manage diabetes in dogs. It contains no added salt or sugar, palm oil, or GMOs, so you don’t have to worry about compromising the health of your pet.

The taste may not be the best, but it offers great spreadability without having any additional ingredients. This small family business also provides personal customer service if you ever need assistance in making a purchase decision.

Refrigerated for thicker consistency according to preference; pair this treat up with Pure Raw & Unfiltered Honey for a delicious breakfast meal each morning before starting out on adventure walks around town?

Pros
  • Excellent source of protein and fiber
  • Vegan-friendly & gluten-free
  • No preservatives/added sugars
  • No palm oil added like other nut butter packets
Cons
  • Taste isn’t as good as expected
  • Texture may be slimier than desired
  • Runnier consistency than expected
  • Price point is higher compared to others

Try IQ bananas chia seeds.

Refrigerate it to form pill pockets or use it as a training treat spread on dog biscuits. It can also be filled in dog puzzle toys. Use this peanut butter with Hyper Pet IQ Treat Mats, which will provide extended playtime treats while keeping boredom at bay! With its rich source of protein and fiber, without added sugar or preservatives, it makes an excellent choice when looking after the healthiest diet possible for your pet companion.

Pros
  • Limited ingredients made in the USA
  • Free from Xylitol, high fructose corn syrup, etc.
  • Suitable for all life stages of dogs
Cons
  • Taste isn’t as good as expected
  • Texture may be slimier than desired
  • Runnier consistency than expected
  • Price point is higher compared to others

Pros:
  • Excellent source of protein and fiber
  • Vegan friendly & gluten-free
  • No preservatives/added sugars
  • No palm oil added like other nut butter packets

Cons:

  • Taste isn’t as good as expected
  • Texture may be slimier than desired
  • Runnier consistency than expected
  • Price point is higher compared to others

Dangers of Xylitol/Birch Sugar in Dogs

Dangers of Xylitol/Birch Sugar in Dogs
Be aware that xylitol, an artificial sweetener commonly found in many brands of peanut butter, is extremely toxic to dogs and can lead to liver failure if ingested. According to the Pet Poison Helpline, xylitol poisoning has increased by over 700% since 2007.

To ensure your dog’s safety when choosing a peanut butter brand for treats or meals, look out for any mention of xylitol on the packaging label.

Fortunately, there are some excellent alternatives available such as natural peanut butters with no added salt or sugars which provide beneficial fatty acids like Omega-3s without adding unnecessary calories.

Organic nut spreads made from sustainably sourced ingredients are also a good option. Additionally, there are speciality blends with chamomile and melatonin formulated specifically for calming anxious pups during stressful events.

To get the most nutrition possible while avoiding potential risks associated with artificial sweeteners like xylitol, opt for products free from preservatives and additives. Check labels carefully before buying and read reviews online about quality control measures taken by manufacturers.

It’s also important to research sustainable production methods used in production processes employed by big-name companies like Big Spoon Roasters’ Peanut Butter line up.

Safe Brands of Peanut Butter for Dogs

Safe Brands of Peanut Butter for Dogs
To ensure your pup’s safety, be sure to choose trusted brands of peanut butter that are free from xylitol and other artificial ingredients. Peanut Butter & Co., Jif Natural, Brad’s Naturals, Hank’s Once Again, Justin’s, and Smucker’s are all dog-safe peanut butter options.

Honest Paws Calm Peanut Butter is a good choice for anxious dogs as it contains chamomile and melatonin, which can help relax them during stressful events.

Everyday Value Organic Peanut Butter is made with no added salt or sugar, making it an excellent source of protein and fiber.

When feeding any type of nut spread, make sure to provide proper portions according to the size of your pup. Too much may lead to weight gain or gastrointestinal distress. Always avoid choking hazards by breaking large pieces into small ones before offering them up as treats.

Additionally, consider healthy fats like Omega 3 intake when choosing between different brands.

It goes without saying: never feed pups artificial sweeteners like xylitol. They can cause serious health problems, including liver failure, if ingested even in small amounts.

Peanut Butter Alternatives for Dogs

Peanut Butter Alternatives for Dogs
For pups looking for a tasty alternative to peanut butter, there are various nut spreads that offer health benefits and delicious flavors. Natural alternatives like almond or cashew butters are great sugar-free options with low glycemic indices.

Vegan options such as sunflower seed butter provide healthy fats without the use of animal products.

When shopping for any type of spread, be sure to read labels carefully before purchasing! Ingredient lists can vary greatly between brands, so it’s important to find one that is safe for your pet pooch.

Nut butters made from vegetable oils often contain oleic acid, which helps promote healthy immune systems in animals while providing energy and essential fatty acids necessary for optimum nutrition levels in dogs.

For those interested in donating an item directly to their local animal shelters, Big Spoon Roasters’ Peanut Butter is an excellent choice as it’s produced using sustainable methods and high-quality ingredients only available through responsible sourcing practices – plus they donate 10% back from every purchase made!

Apple Butter-adjacent peanut butter by Spread The Love offers natural ingredients free of preservatives or additives, making it ideal when crafting homemade dog treats too!

Finally, Hyper Pet’s IQ Treat contains human-grade ingredients packed with protein while promoting licking behavior – a great way to relax your pup during stressful times at home or out on walks together!

Benefits of Peanut Butter for Dogs

Benefits of Peanut Butter for Dogs
You’ll be surprised to find out the numerous benefits that feeding your pup peanut butter can offer! The serving size should always be kept in mind, as too much peanut butter can lead to weight gain and other health issues.

Peanut butter contains beneficial fatty acids like Omega-3s for dogs, which helps keep their coats shiny and healthy while providing a source of protein and low carbs – perfect for those pups with dietary restrictions or allergies.

Apart from giving your pup a protein boost, feeding them natural ingredients without added sugar or salt also has cognitive benefits. Research shows that eating certain kinds of nut butters may improve memory retention among senior dogs.

Finally, there are plenty of brands available offering dog-specific spreads, such as Doggies Natural’s Dog Peanut Nutter spread packed full of vitamins needed by our canine companions, plus Green Coast Pet’s Pawnut Butter produced without preservatives or additives, so finding one suitable won’t take long at all!

Table 1 below provides an overview of some key points about choosing the right kind:

Benefit Feeding Consideration Safety Tips
Omega 3s Serving Size Avoid Xylitol
Protein Boost Allergy Restrictions Natural Ingredients

Which Peanut Butter is Safe and Healthy for Dogs?

Which Peanut Butter is Safe and Healthy for Dogs?
You can spoil your pup with a nutritious and safe treat by choosing the right peanut butter for them! When selecting a good quality product, safety checks should be done to ensure that it’s not only healthy but also free from added sugars or hydrogenated vegetable oils.

Look out for grainy texture peanut butter as they tend to have more natural ingredients than creamy varieties. Natural creamy peanut butter can still make an excellent choice if you’re looking for something smooth and spreadable without any additives.

Also, look out for sugar-free options as these provide a healthier option with added benefits such as good cholesterol levels while avoiding unnecessary calories in their diet.

When feeding, moderation is key – too much of this protein source may cause weight gain in dogs, so portion control should always be monitored when treating your furry friend with this delicious snack!

Not all brands are created equal though; those containing Omega 3s are especially beneficial fatty acids which help keep their coats shiny plus reduce inflammation levels within the body.

What Ingredients Make Peanut Butter Unsafe and Unhealthy for Dogs?

What Ingredients Make Peanut Butter Unsafe and Unhealthy for Dogs?
Be cautious when feeding your pup peanut butter, as some ingredients can make it unsafe and unhealthy for them. Xylitol content is particularly dangerous – this artificial sweetener can be toxic to dogs and should never be included in their diet.

Natural ingredients are the best option; however, some brands contain added sugars or hydrogenated vegetable oils which should also not be consumed by pups. Similarly, beware of products that have excessive fat content or sodium levels which could lead to obesity-related health problems such as diabetes and pancreatitis if eaten in large quantities over time.

It’s important for dog owners to read labels carefully before selecting a safe peanut butter treat! Dog puzzle toys filled with nut butters like Justin’s Peanut Butter or Brad’s Naturals offer an interactive way of providing their snacks without much risk associated with added sugar content found in popular kinds of peanut butter on grocery shelves today.

With so many types available now ranging from organic options to those fortified with Omega 3s, finding one suitable won’t take long at all! By doing research ahead of time on what brands of peanut butter are safe for dogs will ensure you give them only the most nutritious treats while avoiding unnecessary calories intake that could bring harm down the line.

Homemade Peanut Butter for Dogs

Homemade Peanut Butter for Dogs
For those looking for a healthier alternative to store-bought peanut butter, why not try making your own homemade peanut butter specifically tailored to the needs of your pup? DIY recipes are plentiful and easy to follow on the internet.

Look into organic options if you’re concerned about potential allergies or health risks due to additives in commercially available products. Peanut butter is high in protein and healthy fats, which can provide an energy boost while also helping maintain healthy blood sugar levels.

If following brands isn’t your style, plenty of homemade peanut butter recipe videos exist online that allow you control over what ingredients go into each batch – just make sure no artificial sweeteners are used (e.

In addition to being delicious snacks dogs love, incorporating small amounts of natural nut butter into their diet provides nutritional value without taking away from other important food sources they need daily; however, moderation should always be key when feeding treats regardless of type!

The Unhealthy Peanut Butters That Didn’t Make the Cut

The Unhealthy Peanut Butters That Didn’t Make the Cut
It’s important to be aware of unhealthy peanut butters that didn’t make the cut when choosing a product for your pup. Krush Nutrition, Go Nuts, No Cow, and P28 Nuts ‘N More are brands not safe for dogs due to their high xylitol content or other artificial sweeteners.

Labeling mistakes can also lead buyers astray. Ingredients like added sugars can contribute to canine obesity and diabetes, in addition to being an animal byproduct with little nutritional value.

Additionally, many manufacturers add flavoring or extra fat content, which is unnecessary as dogs do not need these components in their diet. They already get enough from regular food sources such as meat proteins and vegetables.

Xylitol itself is extremely toxic, even at small doses, so it’s best avoided altogether! High-fat foods should also be monitored carefully since too much consumption could cause pancreatitis in pups.

The bottom line: read labels carefully and always consult your veterinarian before introducing any new snacks into your pet’s regimen, no matter how healthy they may seem on paper.

Conclusion

It’s important to remember that peanut butter should not be a regular part of your dog’s diet, but rather an occasional treat. Peanut butter is a high-calorie snack that can lead to obesity and diabetes, so it’s important to feed it in moderation and to read all labels carefully.

Like a golden key, the right peanut butter can open the door to a healthier, happier pup. Choose a high-quality peanut butter with natural ingredients, and you can be sure your pup will be safe and satisfied.

So grab the key, unlock the door, and let your pup enjoy the sweet rewards of peanut butter!

References
  • midogguide.com
Avatar for Mutasim Sweileh

Mutasim Sweileh

Mutasim is an author and software engineer from the United States, I and a group of experts made this blog with the aim of answering all the unanswered questions to help as many people as possible.